Combining protocols with the `&` operator - Ideas - Discussions on Python.org
Combining protocols with the `&` operator Ideas typing nachomaiz (Nacho Maiz) January 16, 2024, 2:06pm 1 Would it be of interest to anyone else to be able to combine Protocols with the & operator? This could help address typing issues once a project embraces dependency inversion and starts using small protocols to define interfaces across the entire project. When defining, for example, a Protocol that implements __len__ and __getitem__ , one must currently define your own protocol or inherit from other protocols: from typing import Protocol, TypeVar T_co = TypeVar("T_co", covariant=True) class SizedCollection(Generic[T_co], Protocol): def __len__(self) -> int: ... def __getitem__(self, __key) -> T_co: ... from typing import Sized, Protocol, Generic, TypeVar T_co = TypeVar("T_co", covariant=True) class SizedCollection(Sized, Generic[T_co], Protocol): def __getitem__(self, __key) -> T_co: ...
This idea would enable new protocols to be defined as: from typing import Sized, GetItemProtocol SizedCollection = Sized & GetItemProtocol def func(obj: Sized & GetItemProtocol): ... The type checker would then know that SizedCollection implements the interface defined in Sized AND the hypothetical GetItemProtocol , with the order of operands determining inheritance rules. It could play well with the new generic syntax: type SizedCollection[T] = Sized[T] & GetItemProtocol[T] It also plays well in contrast with the current use of the union | operator to define types, and seems intuitive based on the rest of the typing syntax in my view.
Thoughts? Would love to hear the community’s opinions. 1 Like Daverball (David Salvisberg) January 16, 2024, 2:28pm 2 A more general PEP for type intersections is currently being drafted [1] , I don’t think it makes sense to implement protocol intersections in a separate step, even if it is easier than a more general type intersection. In the meantime there’s this mypy plugin for Protocol intersections: typing-protocol-intersection · PyPI ↩︎ 6 Likes nachomaiz (Nacho Maiz) January 16, 2024, 3:15pm 3 Oh, that’s really great!
I looked through this page and the GitHub issues and didn’t find anything on a first pass. It looks like they are also proposing using A & B for defining intersections, so great timing then! Will be looking forward to developments from the PEP proposal then. Thanks!