Text of issues.guix.gnu.org › 76503 as Styx crawled it on Nov 18, 2026. The page may have changed since. Only its words are kept, without pictures or layout, and only the first part of a long page.

Open the live page

[GCD] Migrating repositories, issues, and patches to Codeberg

Ludovic 2 years ago Benjamin 2 years ago Ashvith 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Cayetano 2 years ago Andrew 2 years ago Leo 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago 45mg 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago 45mg 2 years ago Leo 2 years ago Nicolas 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Hartmut 2 years ago Tomas 2 years ago Tomas 2 years ago runciter 2 years ago Tomas 2 years ago Leo 2 years ago Roman 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Tomas 2 years ago Tomas 2 years ago Konrad 2 years ago Konrad 2 years ago Maxim 2 years ago Ekaitz 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Ekaitz 2 years ago Noé 2 years ago Ekaitz 2 years ago Maxim 2 years ago Maxim 2 years ago Alexis 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Efraim 2 years ago Nicolas 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Maxim 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Carlo 2 years ago 45mg 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Andreas 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Suhail 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Felix 2 years ago Andreas 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Suhail 2 years ago Suhail 2 years ago Felix 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Thompson, 2 years ago Suhail 2 years ago Thompson, 2 years ago Suhail 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Suhail 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Leo 2 years ago Cayetano 2 years ago Konrad 2 years ago 45mg 2 years ago indieterminacy 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Vagrant 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago jbranso 2 years ago Hartmut 2 years ago Hartmut 2 years ago Hartmut 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Vagrant 2 years ago Vivien 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago pinoaffe 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Josep 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Liliana 2 years ago Noé 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Liliana 2 years ago Cayetano 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago pinoaffe 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago pinoaffe 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Jason 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Z572 2 years ago Noé 2 years ago Hilton 2 years ago Andrew 2 years ago Nicolas 2 years ago Greg 2 years ago Divya 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago Vagrant 2 years ago Ekaitz 2 years ago Carmine 2 years ago Steve 2 years ago Andreas 2 years ago Ashish 2 years ago Z572 2 years ago André 2 years ago Ricardo 2 years ago 宋文武 2 years ago Trev 2 years ago Leo 2 years ago pelzflorian 2 years ago Tanguy 2 years ago Ashvith 2 years ago Laurent 2 years ago Sharlatan 2 years ago Janneke 2 years ago Gabriel 2 years ago Ian 2 years ago Maxim 2 years ago Maxim 2 years ago Guillaume 2 years ago Philip 2 years ago Arun 2 years ago Julien 2 years ago Efraim 2 years ago Katherine 2 years ago Tobias 2 years ago Adam 2 years ago Matt 2 years ago Artyom 2 years ago Christopher 2 years ago Eric 2 years ago Steve 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Steve 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Leo 2 years ago Vagrant 2 years ago Felix 2 years ago Steve 2 years ago Simon 2 years ago pinoaffe 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Greg 2 years ago pinoaffe 2 years ago Vagrant 2 years ago Ludovic 2 years ago Vagrant 2 years ago indieterminacy 2 years ago Greg 2 years ago Ekaitz 2 years ago Sébastien 1 years ago Maxim 1 years ago [GCD] Migrating repositories, issues, and patches to Codeberg Done Details 65 participants 45mg Adam Faiz Alexis Simon Andreas Enge Andrew Tropin Arun Isaac Ashish SHUKLA Ashvith Shetty Eric Bavier Carlo Zancanaro Greg Hogan Katherine Cox-Buday Cayetano Santos Divya Ranjan Thompson, David Efraim Flashner Ekaitz Zarraga Carmine Margiotta Felix Lechner Gabriel Wicki Guillaume Le Vaillant Hartmut Goebel Hilton Chain Ian Eure indieterminacy 宋文武 Janneke Nieuwenhuizen jbranso Jason Conroy Josep Bigorra Julien Lepiller Konrad Hinsen Laurent Gatto Leo Famulari Liliana Marie Prikler Ludovic Courtès Christopher Baines Nicolas Goaziou Maxim Cournoyer Matt Tobias Geerinckx-Rice André Batista Nicolas Graves Noé Lopez Noé Lopez pelzflorian (Florian Pelz) Philip McGrath pinoaffe Artyom V.

Poptsov Ricardo Wurmus Roman Riabenko runciter Sébastien Farge Sharlatan Hellseher Benjamin Slade Steve George Suhail Singh Tanguy Le Carrour Trev Vagrant Cascadian Vivien Kraus Andrew Wong Z572 Simon Tournier Tomas Volf Owner unassigned Submitted by Ludovic Courtès Severity normal Debbugs page Hello Guix! This is the formal submission of “Migrating repositories, issues, and patches to Codeberg” (GCD 002), a preliminary draft of which I posted before the Guix Days⁰.

In accordance with the GCD Process, discussion will end on April 23rd at the latest. I would like to remind everyone that you can try out Codeberg either by contributing to one of the Guix-Science repositories¹, or by reviewing or making a pull request for a trivial packaging change (and nothing more!) in my Guix clone at Codeberg: https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guix-devel/2025-02/msg00313.html Please do try it especially if you feel reluctant or wonder what the workflow would be like.

Ludo’. ⁰ https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guix-devel/2025-01/msg00218.html ¹ https://codeberg.org/guix-science title: Migrating repositories, issues, and patches to Codeberg id: 002 status: submitted discussion: https://issues.guix.gnu.org/ number assigned by issue tracker authors: Ludovic Courtès sponsors: Tobias Geerinckx-Rice, Ricardo Wurmus date-submitted: 2025-02-23 date: 2025-02-23 SPDX-License-Identifier: CC-BY-SA-4.0 OR GFDL-1.3-no-invariants-or-later --- # Summary The contribution workflow in Guix has been facing several challenges: difficult onboarding, lack of legibility, complex, unreliable, and labor-intensive infrastructure, and lack of automation.

All these lead to an experience that contributors often find frustrating and hinders quality assurance efforts. We propose to address these limitations by migrating repositories, issue tracking, and patch tracking to Codeberg, a “modern” forge hosted by a non-profit. # Motivation To keep track of bug reports and patches, Guix historically chose tools that were *simple* in their design: - bug reports and patches can be sent by plain email, without having to create an account or even subscribe to a mailing list; - discussion and patch review happen naturally by email, without requiring special tools; - the Debbugs instance at https://bugs.gnu.org keeps track of bug reports and patches by assigning them an identifier and creating a mailing list specifically for each bug or patch.

However, to overcome several limitations, the project developed processes and tools, which can be characterized as *incidental complexity*: - because the Debbugs web interface is crude by today’s standards and hard to search and navigate, the project developed [mumi]( https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/guix/mumi.git/), the web interface running at https://issues.guix.gnu.org; - to navigate bugs and patches more conveniently than what an email client supports, contributors were [encouraged]( https://guix.gnu.org/manual/devel/en/html_node/Debbugs-User-Interfaces.html) to use interfaces like `debbugs.el` or `b4`; - sending pat

The rest of this page is on the live site.